How to set up replenishment reminder emails on Shopify
A setup guide for Shopify replenishment emails: which products to pick, how to set the delay, consent rules, what the email needs, and how to test it first.
On this page8 sections
- What a replenishment reminder is (and is not)
- Step 1: Choose the products that run out
- Step 2: Set the delay
- Step 3: Only email customers who agreed to marketing
- Step 4: Write an email that does one job
- Step 5: Test before anything goes live
- Step 6: Decide how you will measure it
- Doing this with BuyAgainFlow
A replenishment reminder is one email, sent to a customer who bought something they will run out of, at about the time they are likely to need it again. It names the product they bought and gives them a fast way back to it.
This guide covers what to decide before you send one: the products, the delay, who may receive it, what the email must contain, and how to check it before real customers see it. The steps apply whether you use a general email platform or a dedicated app.
What a replenishment reminder is (and is not)
A replenishment reminder is triggered by a paid order for a specific product and sent after a delay you choose. It differs from the other emails you might already send:
- Not a newsletter. It goes to one customer about one product they bought, not to a list.
- Not a subscription. Nothing is charged automatically. The customer decides each time. (We compare the two in a separate guide.)
- Not a cart-abandonment email. It follows a completed purchase, not an unfinished one.
Step 1: Choose the products that run out
Start with products a customer uses up at a fairly steady rate: supplements, coffee, skincare, pet food, filters, cleaning refills. Leave out gift cards, one-time purchases and items with no natural "running low" moment.
If you sell sizes or bundles that last very different lengths of time, note that now. A 90-capsule bottle and a 30-capsule bottle should not be reminded on the same day. Many teams set the delay per product, or split products into a few groups that last about as long.
Pick a short list first, ideally the two or three consumables that most first-time buyers order. You can add more once you have seen how the first ones behave.
Step 2: Set the delay
The delay is the number of days between the paid order and the email. A practical starting point is how long the product lasts, minus a few days so the reminder arrives before the last dose, not after it. Klaviyo's help center gives the example of a 30-day supplement reminded about 25 days after purchase (Klaviyo (opens in a new tab)).
Once you have repeat orders, replace the estimate with what your customers actually do. Our guide to choosing reorder reminder timing walks through both methods.
Step 3: Only email customers who agreed to marketing
A reminder is a marketing email, so it should go only to customers who accepted email marketing. On Shopify, customers can opt in at checkout when the email marketing checkbox is turned on under Settings > Checkout (Shopify Help Center (opens in a new tab)).
Two rules keep you on the right side of your customers and the law:
- Check consent close to sending, not only at the time of the order. A customer can unsubscribe in between.
- Put an unsubscribe link in every reminder and honor it before the next send.
Step 4: Write an email that does one job
The reminder should be short and specific:
- Subject and preview text that name the product, for example "Running low on Daily Magnesium?"
- The product photo and name, so the customer recognizes it at a glance.
- One clear button. Send it straight to the product they bought, not to your home page. On Shopify, a cart permalink (opens in a new tab) can pre-load a cart with a specific variant and quantity.
- Your store's look: store name and brand color, so it reads as your email.
Skip the discount on the first reminder. It is a service email, and a customer who needs the product does not need a coupon to reorder it.
Step 5: Test before anything goes live
Before you switch reminders on, send yourself a test email and check:
- the subject, preview text and button label read well on a phone;
- the product image is the right one;
- the button opens the right product and variant;
- the unsubscribe link works.
Then watch the first real reminders closely. A good tool shows you every scheduled, sent and skipped reminder, and why.
Step 6: Decide how you will measure it
Before you start, decide what counts as a reorder. A clear rule is: a paid order, by the customer who clicked the reminder, for the same product variant, within a set window after the click. Exclude refunded and cancelled orders. Our guide to measuring repeat purchase revenue in Shopify explains how to combine this with Shopify's own customer reports.
Doing this with BuyAgainFlow
BuyAgainFlow is a Shopify app built for exactly this one flow, set up inside Shopify Admin:
- Products and timing: turn reminders on per product and pick a delay of 14, 30, 45, 60 or 90 days, or any whole number from 7 to 180, or use your store default.
- Consent: reminders are scheduled only for customers who accepted email marketing, and the app checks with Shopify again right before each email.
- The email: edit the subject, preview text, headline, message and button label, with your store name, brand color and the product photo from your catalog. Send yourself a test first.
- The button: Buy Again opens your Shopify checkout with the same product, variant and quantity. The customer reviews and pays as usual. Your store needs the Online Store sales channel.
- Results: Activity lists every reminder and why it was sent, skipped or cancelled. Home shows attributed reorder revenue.
The help center walks through each setup step.
Try it on your store
BuyAgainFlow sets this up inside Shopify Admin: products, timing, a branded email and a Buy Again button that opens checkout with the same item.
Install on the Shopify App Store (opens in a new tab)Replenishment reminders for Shopify
One branded email per product, at the delay you choose.
Install on Shopify (opens in a new tab)