Skip to content

How to measure repeat purchase revenue in Shopify

Which Shopify reports show repeat customers and returning revenue, how to read cohort analysis, and how to credit reorders to a replenishment email without overcounting.

On this page6 sections
  1. Where to find repeat customers in Shopify
  2. Read the cohort analysis, not only the totals
  3. Measuring revenue from repeat orders
  4. Attributing reorders to a reminder email
  5. Mistakes that inflate the numbers
  6. How BuyAgainFlow reports reorders

"Are customers coming back?" sounds like one question. In practice it is three:

  1. How many customers order again? (repeat rate)
  2. How much revenue comes from those repeat orders? (returning revenue)
  3. How much of that did a specific email cause? (attribution)

Shopify's built-in reports answer the first two. The third needs a clear rule, and it is the one most often overstated.

Where to find repeat customers in Shopify

In your Shopify admin, go to Analytics > Reports and filter the category to Customers (Shopify Help Center (opens in a new tab)). The reports most useful for repeat purchases are:

  • New vs returning customers. Counts first-time and returning customers for each day, week or month. Shopify counts a customer as returning when their order history already includes at least one order.
  • Returning customers. Lists every customer with two or more orders, with first and latest order dates, order count and total spent.
  • One-time customers. Lists customers with exactly one order. This is the group a replenishment reminder is meant to move.
  • Customer cohort analysis. Groups customers by the month of their first order and shows how many came back in each later period.

Note one detail from Shopify's documentation: customer reports use each customer's entire order history, not only the dates you selected. A customer who first bought in November and again in December shows as a repeat customer in a November report.

Read the cohort analysis, not only the totals

A rising returning-customer count can simply mean you acquired more customers last year. Cohorts separate the two effects.

In the Customer cohort analysis report, each row is the group of customers whose first order fell in the same month. The columns show what that group did in month 1, month 2 and so on after their first order. You can change the metric to customer retention rate, net sales or average order value, and filter cohorts by the first order's product name (Shopify Help Center (opens in a new tab)).

For a replenishment program, the useful questions are:

  • What share of a month's new customers order again by month 1, month 2 and month 3?
  • Does that share change for cohorts after you started sending reminders?
  • For cohorts whose first order included your main consumable, how does month-1 retention compare with other cohorts?

Compare cohorts of similar size and season. A December cohort full of gift buyers will not behave like a March cohort.

Measuring revenue from repeat orders

To see revenue rather than customer counts, switch the cohort metric to net sales, or export the Returning customers report and sum the spend of customers whose first order falls in the period you are studying.

Be specific about what you include:

  • Use net sales, which already subtract discounts, returns and refunds, rather than gross sales.
  • Fix the time window. "Revenue from customers acquired in Q1, in the 90 days after their first order" is comparable from quarter to quarter. "All revenue from returning customers" is not.

Attributing reorders to a reminder email

Store-wide repeat revenue includes customers who would have come back anyway. To credit an email, you need a rule that links an order to that email. A conservative rule has four parts:

  1. Same customer. The order is placed by the customer who received and clicked the reminder.
  2. Same product. The order includes the product variant the reminder was about.
  3. Within a window. The order happens within a fixed number of days after the click.
  4. Paid and kept. Refunded and cancelled orders are excluded.

Count the line amount of the reminded product, not the whole order, if you want the figure to describe the reminder rather than the basket.

Even this rule measures orders that followed a reminder click, not proof that the email caused them. If you want a causal answer, hold out a random group of customers who receive no reminder and compare their repeat rate with the group that does.

Mistakes that inflate the numbers

  • Counting opens as success. Mail apps prefetch images, so opens are unreliable. Use clicks and orders.
  • Counting any order after the email. Without "same product" and a window, every loyal customer's next order gets credited.
  • Ignoring refunds. A refunded reorder is not revenue.
  • Comparing to last year without cohorts. Growth in new customers looks like growth in retention.

How BuyAgainFlow reports reorders

BuyAgainFlow uses the conservative rule above. An order counts as an attributed reorder when it is a paid order for the same product variant by the same customer, placed within your attribution window after they clicked Buy Again. You set the window from 7 to 90 days (30 by default). Refunded and voided orders are excluded, and revenue is the line amount of that product.

The app's Home page shows attributed reorder revenue. Activity lists every reminder with its status (scheduled, sent, skipped or cancelled) and the reason. Use these alongside Shopify's cohort report, not instead of it. See Understanding Results and Activity.

Try it on your store

BuyAgainFlow sets this up inside Shopify Admin: products, timing, a branded email and a Buy Again button that opens checkout with the same item.

Install on the Shopify App Store (opens in a new tab)