How to choose reorder reminder timing for each product
How to pick the delay for a replenishment reminder: start from how long the product lasts, adjust for shipping and pack size, then refine with your own repeat-order data.
On this page7 sections
The timing of a reorder reminder decides most of its value. Too early and the customer still has plenty, so they ignore it. Too late and they have already bought again, from you or from someone else.
There is no single right number of days. There is a reliable way to find a good one for each product, and then to improve it.
Start from how long the product lasts
For products with a fixed number of servings, the supply is simple arithmetic:
Days of supply = servings in the pack ÷ servings used per day × quantity bought
A 60-capsule bottle taken twice a day lasts about 30 days. Two bottles last about 60.
For products used at a less predictable rate (a face serum, a bag of coffee for a household), use your best estimate of typical use and treat it as a first guess you will correct later.
Send before the supply runs out
The reminder should arrive while the customer still has some product left, with enough time to order and receive more. A common approach is to subtract a few days for the reorder to ship:
First reminder ≈ days of supply − shipping time − a few days of buffer
Two published examples of this idea:
- Klaviyo suggests reminding about 25 days after purchase for a 30-day supplement (Klaviyo Help Center (opens in a new tab)).
- Mailchimp suggests reminding once a product is about 70% used, the 21-day mark for a 30-day supply (Mailchimp (opens in a new tab)).
If your reminders are triggered by the order date rather than delivery, remember that the customer only starts using the product once it arrives.
Adjust for pack size and quantity
Quantity matters as much as the product. A customer who bought three bags does not need the one-bag reminder. If your tool reminds the same product on one schedule regardless of quantity, consider setting the delay around the size most customers buy, or creating separate products for multi-packs.
Refine with your own repeat-order data
Once you have a few months of orders, measure what your customers actually do. For one product:
- Export orders that include the product (Shopify admin: Orders > Export).
- For each customer who bought it more than once, calculate the days between consecutive purchases.
- Take the median of those gaps. It is less distorted by a few very slow reorderers than the average.
- Set the reminder a little before the median, so it reaches most customers before they would normally reorder.
Check the result every few months, and after any change to pack sizes or pricing.
A worked example (illustrative numbers)
Suppose a 30-serving protein powder, one scoop a day, ships in about 4 days.
| Step | Days |
|---|---|
| Days of supply | 30 |
| Minus shipping time | −4 |
| Minus buffer | −3 |
| First estimate | about 23 |
If your tool offers fixed delays, pick the nearest one that still arrives before the customer runs out. Later, if your order data shows a median reorder gap of, say, 34 days, you would move the reminder later.
These numbers are for illustration only, not benchmarks.
Common timing mistakes
- One delay for the whole store. Different products run out at different times.
- Ignoring quantity. Multi-packs need longer delays.
- Never revisiting the number. Your first guess should be replaced by real reorder gaps.
- Reminding after a reorder. If the customer already bought again, a reminder is noise. Make sure reorders cancel or reset pending reminders where your tool allows it.
Setting timing in BuyAgainFlow
In BuyAgainFlow you set a store default delay and can give any product its own delay. Presets are 14, 30, 45, 60 or 90 days after a paid order, and you can enter any whole number from 7 to 180. Each reminder is scheduled when Shopify reports the paid order and sent at that product's delay.
You also set the attribution window, from 7 to 90 days (30 by default): how long after a Buy Again click a paid order for the same variant counts as an attributed reorder. See Configuring timing in the help center.
Try it on your store
BuyAgainFlow sets this up inside Shopify Admin: products, timing, a branded email and a Buy Again button that opens checkout with the same item.
Install on the Shopify App Store (opens in a new tab)Replenishment reminders for Shopify
One branded email per product, at the delay you choose.
Install on Shopify (opens in a new tab)